I read an article/blog two weeks ago about Sexism in Fantasy stories that has really bothered me. I left it pinned to the top of my Facebook feed, so I could re-read it a couple of times, while trying to figure out what was bothering me. You can read it there, or I’ll try to post a link…
http://mythcreants.com/blog/five-signs-your-story-is-sexist/?platform=hootsuite Yes? No? Whatever, just go check it out on my Facebook page, I’ll sort it out later.
What bothers me is not just this individual article/blog, but the way so many people are pointing fingers at books, blaming them for perpetuating the ills of modern society. Even the students of higher learning–the place you go to expand and challenge yourself–have started protesting the books assigned for the course by the teacher. It made them uncomfortable.
The above article/blog continued the finger pointing, and because it hit on one of my favorite genres it caught my attention. I have read the books it was accusing of sexism, and I had opinions. Opinions somewhat similar to the blogger in some ways, but widely dissimilar in others. If you really tried to follow this blogger’s suggestions, you would have to not include females in your story at all, for fear of making them too trope-y. But that would be sexist, so maybe you could make all of your characters females. But, wait, isn’t that sexist, too?
I guess I don’t like being told to play it safe. It made me uncomfortable.
Also, allowances weren’t made for the age of some of the books, and it’s unfair to expect writers of past generations to have the same sensitivities as a modern writer. We are going through a very painful stage of growth as a society, trying to understand the deep hooks of misogyny, and how to pull them out without doing more damage than they are causing.
I admit it, I have hot buttons, too. (Skinny-shaming is a big one for me.) A trip through ‘multi-media land’ makes me unhappy on a daily basis, with advertising, memes and all forms of entertainment subtly–and not so subtly–trying to maintain the status quo. I think the point of no return-to-the-kitchen has been passed, and we must all work together to redefine ourselves as humans, not a specific gender of human.
Meanwhile, let’s explore what makes us uncomfortable. Discomfort is where you find your internal boundaries. What direction does your moral compass point? Is it a fair direction, for EVERYBODY? Do your boundaries allow humans to be free, or force them to conform to your personal view of the world? Has a book or other story made you feel uncomfortable? How did that make you feel about the writer? Were you angry someone wrote such trash?
Banning books has always been a questionable behavior for me. You are giving free publicity to something you seem to hate, somehow unaware that you’re working against your actual wants; for people to not read THAT book.
You know… THAT book. The one with sex, or magic, or rape, or swords, or homosexuality, or dragons, or bondage, or aliens, or death, or drugs, or war, or slavery, or racism, or sexism, or classism, or icky-ism, or something-ism, or we-don’t-talk-about-that-ism.
Often, the words beginning the protest are, “I haven’t read the book, but…” Please, stop. With those words, you have lost all credibility, and I really don’t care what your uninformed opinion is. Writing and reading are subtle arts, and reading a line or two does not convey the place of those lines IN a story. If this concept is too advanced for you, maybe you shouldn’t be the one trying to decide what other people can read.
The writer’s mirror reflects our society. That is its job. To show you the past, the now, and the future. What we were, who we are, and what we could be. Some writers show the positive side of society, some the negative, but most seem to show a mix of both. Setting, character, plot, and technique all are tools of the writer trying to tell a story. I believe every story is telling us something important, and needs to be told. We need to listen. We need to be made uncomfortable. I hope I will make my readers uncomfortable.
For now, I will polish the mirror.